“There is nothing noble in being superior to your fellow man; true nobility is being superior to your former self.”--Ernest Hemingway
Masculinity, queer theory argues, is often overrated. Scholarship from queer theorists generally relies on femininity and the construct of the feminine in their narratives. One only needs to read Eve Sedgwick to understand the gravitational pull of femininity in queerness. Such a gravitational pull has ramifications beyond queer theory; when one thinks of gender, one thinks mainly of femininity. That is why, in this paper, I will focus on masculine narratives.
Both Ernest Hemingway and F. Scott Fitzgerald have similar characters in their respective stories. No characters are more similar, however, than Jordan Baker from The Great Gatsby and Bret from The Sun Also Rises. Bret emasculates Jake Barnes by becoming cynical when Jake asks Bret to become his girlfriend. “Isn’t it pretty to think so?” is the closing line that Bret delivers to Jake, dismissing any chances to become his girlfriend.
Jordan is similarly cynical, repeatedly rebuffing any chance that Nick Carraway gives her to become his girlfriend. Fitzgerald gives a detailed description of Jordan, writing that her hair is “styled like that of a man.” In this way, Jordan and Bret similarly emasculate each other, from their male names to their similarly male attire.
The ways in which both Fitzgerald and Hemingway visit masculinity is similar
in not only style but form. Fitzgerald writes that Jordan had a curiously masculine way about her, noting the way in which she both moved and thought. He also writes that Jordan had a curiously masculine name, as curiously masculine as the first name that Hemingway gives Bret.
When Nick first meets Jordan, he is surprised and wants to be with her, similarly like the feelings that Jake has towards Jordan. Nick is entranced by Jordan and follows her around everywhere she goes. Fitzgerald writes that both Nick and Jordan are meant to be together, similarly like the way that Hemingway treats both Jake and Bret before their union inevitably dissolves.
There is no way to deny the gravitational pull that each has towards masculinity. By understanding both Jordan and Bret as masculine characters, we can better understand how they work both with and against each other.